| Eric Fermier | Infield | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Phil Ferranti | Infield | Monroe Community College |
| Sean Flannery | Infield | Monroe Community College |
| Sam Loew | Infield | Monroe Community College |
| Padraig O'Shaughnessy | Infield | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Cas Sobaszek | Infield | Monroe Community College |
| Trey Brown | Outfield | Monroe Community College |
| Logan Martella | Outfield | Monroe Community College |
| Brandon Scheidemantle | Outfield | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Robert Korff | Catcher | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Evan Magill | Catcher | Monroe Community College |
| Alex Cardona | Pitcher | Mercyhurst University - North East |
| Matt Petrossi | Pitcher | Monroe Community College |